Skip to content
We earn advertising and referral fees from many of the brands we rank, and those fees affect where they appear.

Top3 Mattress compares mattresses sold in Australia, and we make our money when a reader buys through one of our links. Brands pay us advertising and referral fees, and those arrangements affect which mattresses we cover and how high they sit in our rankings. Some mattresses here have no arrangement with us at all.

Every mattress is scored against the same ten published criteria, and each of the ten scores is shown alongside the total. What those criteria measure, and how the total is set, are laid out on our How we rate page. The work behind the scores is desk work: we read published specifications, warranty documents and trial terms, and cross-check them against each manufacturer's own pages. We do not buy these mattresses and sleep on them, and no score here comes from in-home testing.

We do not cover every mattress sold in Australia, and the ones we can earn a commission on are more likely to be among the ones we do cover. Prices, trial lengths and warranty terms change without notice, so check the brand's own page before you buy. A ranking here is not a guarantee about a product and not an endorsement of it. Our full terms are set out in the Terms of use.

Head to head

Emma vs TEMPUR

Neither can be adjusted, so this comes down to what you are buying and how much protection you get if it is wrong. Emma is a spring hybrid with a 150-night trial. TEMPUR is all-foam using TEMPUR's own material, 20 cm deep, with no sleep trial of any kind, but its ten-year warranty is stated as full replacement rather than pro-rata.

Direct Verdict & Recommendation Answer-First Comparison

The Short Answer: Which mattress should you choose?

Neither can be adjusted, so this comes down to what you are buying and how much protection you get if it is wrong. Emma is a spring hybrid with a 150-night trial. TEMPUR is all-foam using TEMPUR's own material, 20 cm deep, with no sleep trial of any kind, but its ten-year warranty is stated as full replacement rather than pro-rata.

  • Price Advantage: Emma starts lower at From $1,759.
  • Cooling & Airflow: Emma leads cooling with a score of 8.9/10.
  • Trial Guarantee: Emma gives 150 nights vs TEMPUR with No sleep trial.

Key differences at a glance

Build & Feel

Construction & Alignment

Emma: Hybrid (Pocket Spring + Memory Foam) (Medium-Soft)

TEMPUR: All-foam (TEMPUR Material) (Medium)

Comfort Scores

Cooling & Motion Transfer

Emma: Cooling 8.9/10, Motion 8.8/10

TEMPUR: Cooling 7.2/10, Motion 9.2/10

Purchase Terms

Trial, Price & Warranty

Emma: From $1,759 · 150 nights trial · 10 years warranty

TEMPUR: From $1,799 · No sleep trial trial · 10 years (full replacement) warranty

The differences that matter

Emma compared with TEMPUR
Specification Emma TEMPUR
Entry price From $1,759 (better of the two) From $1,799
Sleep trial 150 nights (better of the two) No sleep trial
Warranty 10 years 10 years (full replacement)
Overall score 9.1 (better of the two) 8.5
Cooling score 8.9/10 (better of the two) 7.2/10
Motion isolation score 8.8/10 9.2/10 (better of the two)
Edge support score 9/10 (better of the two) 7.4/10
Firmness Medium-Soft Medium
Construction Hybrid (Pocket Spring + Memory Foam) All-foam (TEMPUR Material)
Height / Profile 26 cm 20 cm
Key materials 7-zone pocket springs, Reinforced perimeter foam frame, ThermoSync graphite foam, PolarLuxe cover TEMPUR Adapt material, DuraBase support layer, Washable cover
Delivery & returns Free to select metro areas · 1–3 working days —

Scores, pricing, trials and warranties highlight the category leader. Firmness, materials and profile dimensions are listed as individual sleeping preferences rather than absolute winners.

Final recommendation: Which one is right for you?

These two suit different sleepers. Use the criteria below to match your body type, sleeping position and temperature needs to the right choice.

Choose Emma if…

You have not slept on TEMPUR material before, or you want a trial period at all.

Check Emma price

Choose TEMPUR if…

You already know TEMPUR material suits you and you want the cheapest way into it.

Check TEMPUR price

Pros and cons, side by side

Emma

Pros

  • A 150-night trial — 30 nights more than Newentor, Origin or Koala, 50 more than Ecosa
  • A foam frame around the springs, so the edge holds when you sit on it
  • Cooling is built into all three layers: graphite foam, a polyethylene-blend cover and an open spring core
  • Seven support zones across the length of the bed

Cons

  • Medium-soft is the only firmness Emma makes, so there is no firmer version to switch to
  • Free delivery and returns cover select metro addresses only; outer and regional areas pay a fee
  • Delivery fees are not refunded if you return it inside the trial
  • No foam or textile certification is published

TEMPUR

Pros

  • The warranty is stated as full replacement for the whole ten years, not pro-rata
  • TEMPUR’s own material is the reference point for pressure-relieving foam, and this is the cheapest way into it
  • The cover unzips and washes at 30 °C
  • Seven retailers stock it, so you can shop the price rather than take one seller’s number

Cons

  • There is no sleep trial at all — neither TEMPUR nor the retailer offers one
  • Medium is the only feel, so if it is wrong for you there is nothing to switch to
  • At 20 cm there is less comfort layer to work with than in a typical 25–30 cm build
  • The warranty does not publish an indentation depth, so the test a claim is judged against is not stated

Emma vs TEMPUR: Frequently Asked Questions

Is Emma or TEMPUR better for back support and spinal alignment?

Emma: Hybrid (Pocket Spring + Memory Foam), firmness Medium-Soft. TEMPUR: All-foam (TEMPUR Material), firmness Medium. As a general rule, zoned pocket-spring hybrids push back more under the lower back and hips, while all-foam builds contour more closely around the shoulders and hips. Firmness preference matters as much as construction.

Which mattress sleeps cooler in Australian climates: Emma or TEMPUR?

Emma scores higher for cooling: 8.9/10 against 7.2/10 for TEMPUR. The cooling score is our assessment of each brand's published materials and construction; we do not run temperature tests.

How do the trial periods and warranties compare between Emma and TEMPUR?

Emma: sleep trial 150 nights; warranty 10 years. TEMPUR: no sleep trial; warranty 10 years (full replacement). Trial conditions such as minimum nights, return fees and delivery areas differ between brands, so read each brand's terms before you buy.

Other match-ups

Want a third column? Build your own comparison with up to three mattresses.